Guy Thomas Evans

Casualty Report No. 1

The vacuum cleaner that sold flights.

AParticulars

In 1992 Hoover offered two free return flights to anyone who spent £100 on its products. Then it offered America. This is the record of what followed.

Company
Hoover Europe, a subsidiary of Maytag Corporation (owned since 1989)
What failed
A sales promotion
Period
August 1992 to June 1994, with claims in court until at least December 1996
Recorded cost to the owner
About $73m before tax, 1992–94
Report dated
Sources
Listed below, each graded

BSummary

In August 1992 Hoover Europe offered two free return flights to Europe to anyone in Britain who spent £100 or more on Hoover products. Before the year was out, the destinations included New York and Orlando.1

The cheapest qualifying product was a vacuum cleaner at £119. Many people bought one. Fewer of them wanted a vacuum cleaner.2

The promotion was meant to sell appliances. It sold flights. Maytag recorded about $73m of costs before tax. Three executives were dismissed. In 1995 Maytag sold Hoover Europe to Candy of Italy and agreed to keep paying for the flights.3

CThe money, drawn

Fig. 1. Recorded costs to Maytag, in US dollars, as filed. The band’s width is the cumulative pretax cost of the promotion; the drop is the loss on the sale of Hoover Europe. Both are drawn to one scale, so the drop can be read against the band. Between filing dates the edges are straight lines. How I know: A, a primary record.

DSequence of events

Each line carries its date as the record gives it, its source, and how sure I am of it.

  1. 11989

    Maytag Corporation of Newton, Iowa, acquires Hoover Europe with Chicago Pacific Corp.

  2. 2August 1992

    The offer opens: spend £100 on Hoover products, claim two return flights to Europe. Qualifying purchases run to January 1993.

    Maytag, Form 10-K for 1993. How I know: A.

    UPI, 31 March and 29 September 1993: £100. How I know: B.

  3. 3Late 1992

    The offer is extended to New York and Orlando. Accounts differ on the month.

    UPI, 31 March and 27 April 1993: December. Later accounts: November. How I know: B.

  4. 410 December 1992

    A minister tells the Commons that no additional controls over free-flight offers are necessary.

    Hansard, written answer. How I know: A.

  5. 517 February 1993

    The same minister has no evidence that such offers are other than bona fide sales promotions.

    Hansard, written answer. How I know: A.

  6. 6March 1993

    An estimated 200,000 people have claimed tickets to the United States.

    UPI, 31 March 1993: “an estimated 200,000”. How I know: C.

  7. 731 March 1993

    Maytag dismisses the president of Hoover Europe, the vice president of UK marketing and the director of marketing services. Its chairman calls the promotions “flawed”.

    UPI, 31 March and 27 April 1993. How I know: B.

  8. 8First quarter 1993

    Maytag takes a special charge of $50m before tax and reports a quarterly net loss of $10.5m.

    Maytag, Form 10-K for 1995: the charge. How I know: A.

    UPI, 27 April 1993: the loss. How I know: C.

  9. 922 June 1993

    Parliament asks whether Royal Mail changed how registered letters reached the promotion’s address. It had not. The agency signed for them in the usual way.

    Hansard, written answer. How I know: A.

  10. 1029 September 1993

    Trading standards decide not to prosecute. Hoover has flown 103,000 people. Another 12,500 a month are still taking up the offer.

    UPI, 29 September 1993; the numbers are Hoover’s, as reported. How I know: C.

  11. 1122 March 1994

    An Early Day Motion records that Hoover’s own travel firm, Your Leisure, is selling transatlantic return tickets to bucket shops for as little as £139.

    Early Day Motion 913, citing the Evening Standard of 17 March 1994. How I know: A.

  12. 12June 1994

    The deadline for every flight under the terms.

  13. 1330 May 1995

    Maytag agrees to sell Hoover Europe to Candy S.p.A. It completes at $164.3m, with an after-tax loss of $135.4m. Maytag agrees to cover free-flights claims beyond the reserve.

  14. 14December 1996

    Customers who never flew are still taking Hoover to court.

EContributing factors

The offer was worth more than the product. Two transatlantic return flights were offered against a £119 vacuum cleaner. The promotion therefore attracted people who wanted flights, and it attracted them in proportion to how good the flights were.4

The plan relied on people not claiming. A trade-press account written in 2005 says the business case assumed most buyers would be put off by the paperwork. TIME reported conditions that “seemed designed to discourage customers”. Paperwork deters some people. It does not deter 200,000.5

Nobody owned the downside. The bookings went to travel companies working for Hoover, which could not meet the demand. The chairman said as much. By 1994 one of them was selling transatlantic seats to bucket shops while customers waited for theirs.6

FWhat an owner can take from this

  1. 1Cost every offer at full take-up. If the business can’t afford everyone saying yes, it can’t afford the offer.
  2. 2When the gift is worth more than the product, you’re selling the gift.
  3. 3Put one named person in charge of the downside before launch, with the authority to stop it.

A note on the people involved

Thousands of customers spent money and time and never flew; some spent years in court.7 Staff at Hoover’s factories worked through a surge in demand that was never going to last.8 The report is about the decisions.

GHow I know

Each source carries one of four grades, as in every margin above. The key is at the foot of every page, and in full in the small print.

A, a primary record
B or C
C, one report, or my own judgement

Figures in dollars are Maytag’s own, as filed. The pound totals often quoted (£40m to £50m) could not be traced to a primary source and are left out.

Not printed: the widely repeated cost of £48m, the expected 50,000 applications and the loss of a Royal Warrant. None could be traced to a source I could open.